If you are making money on the internet through the means of blogging, then more than likely you are commenting on blogs to get links pointing back to your site. Now this is not the best way to move up in the search engines, as blog comments are not valued like they used to be when it comes to moving up in the search engines, but, it is a way to get your blog noticed and some decent exposure if you are commenting on blogs the right way.
The thing is I hate blog commenting. I much would rather pay someone else to do it for me. But finding a reliable source to do so is the hardest part. There are many blog commenting services that are out there but most of them are crap, so I am trying to narrow them down to the best ones for the money.
I am on the quest to find out what is the best blog commenting service that is out there. I will be putting a couple of months of work into this post and I will be updating it as I get and monitor my results that I have got from the blog commenting service. As every one here knows that blog commenting can increase your pagerank and also increase your rankings for the keyword that you are targeting. I will be updating these services that I have used as I get the reports back from them, so just because they are numbered won’t mean that I think that will be the best one.
1. Blogcommentingservice.net $30 for 50 Comments
The first blog commenting service that I tried out came from blogcommentingservice.net, which I believe is joined with another site as that is what I got in my report. Anyway this is by far the cheapest blog commenting service that I have ran across, and I guess that you get what you pay for, you can’t expect much for paying only $30 for 50 do-follow blog comments.
They send you pretty detailed reports about what page your comment was left on, along with the comment that was written. But after 20 days of getting my report I decided to go to each site that my blog was submitted to one by one to see how effective it was. Out of the 50 comments submitted, only 16 of them actually showed up when I visited the page, and only 16 of them were do-follow anchored text links.
Out of those 16, more than half of them were on pages that were flooded and spammed with blog comments on pages with a 0 or n/a pagerank. I think there were about 6-7 comments that might have done my site some justice when it comes to blog commenting for seo purposes.
The other 34 pages I checked in the report, my comment was either non-existent or were no-follow comments that were accompanied by 1,000′s of UGG boots anchored text’s, which does your site no good when your link is on a page that is considered nothing but spam.
But for only $30 what can you expect. The site I had used the commenting service for did manage to get over 400 yahoo links indexed though because of the 50 comment submission run, although I know that will be narrowed down to about 30 yahoo links in a month or so. The comments were actually pretty thorough though, so the commenters do know how to comment on blogs, maybe my keywords I used in my anchor text were a little to spammy for the blog owners, who knows. So far this is the best blog commenting service I have used…
2.www.unlimitedtraffic.net $50 for 50 comments
Now I used this service about 5 months ago. Never really saw many links show up and really didn’t have the patience to check the report that they sent me to see if all of my links were approved or not. I also never noticed my yahoo links from the site I was using go above 50 either, which is not a good thing when you are blog commenting on multiple blogs. I can get any blog over 1000 yahoo links on any given day by commenting on 20-30 blogs, though the links will decrease, in time, it is still a way to see if your links are showing up.
But today I looked at the report they sent me 4-5 months ago, and I think 3 of the 50 links were still there. All of the other comments were either never approved, or deleted because of poor commenting. Not sure, and the keyword anchor I used wasn’t spamming at all, so with that being said, I will never be using their blog commenting service again and wouldn’t recommend anyone else doing so unless they up their quality of comments they leave and find some more better blogs to leave comments on.
3. Ultraseosolutions.com I got package #4, 250 do-follow blog comments for $60
Oh wow about this one, I did get 300 comments on the report. I started to check the comments one by one to see where I was getting them from, and it seems most of these were automated on crappy spammed commented pages. There were a couple of pages that my url was on that had less than a 100 comments, according to the report, but when I checked my link was nowhere to be found. Basically every link I checked, was on posts that has 1000 comments plus on them, spammed to hell.
But then again, what can you really expect for $60, surely not 250 legit do-follow comments with an anchored text of your choice, on posts that have less than 100 comments. I’m not bitching, because they do offer to replace links that have disapeared, but if they are replaced with the same low quality comment links from pages that have been spammed to hell, they can keep them, as I have no proof that leaving links on high spammed pages can hurt your Serp ranking, but I can’t see how it can help at all. Sure your yahoo link index may rise, but that is about all this blog commenting service is good for, as a final vote, I don’t recommend it.
Stay tuned as I will be updating all of the major blog commenting services that are around and giving you the pro’s and con’s of using each service 
I am very skeptical that there is really a legitimate blog commenting service out there that is worth the money for paying, if anyone has had experience with a good blog commenting service then please feel free to leave a comment.
{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }
I just found your website and I am going to keep checking you out. I am also trying to make money online and it is nice to find someone who is new and starting out. I hope I am able to take some of your lessons and put it to use for myself.
First off thanks for sharing your commenting service experience, as a blogger I actually find commenting services a little distasteful as they don’t allow for “interaction” when I respond to comments I typically expect a reply and an interaction, most commenting services will comment once and never come by again even if you replied to their comment.
I am sure they compile a list of known DoFollow blogs and sometimes they switch to nofollow or use a plugin that nofollow’s comments until a certain amount are approved first. But my question is how much is $30 worth for you, how long could you leave 50 comments just by visiting something like Comluv.com or BlogEngage.com and commenting on the 50 most recent articles? I could probably leave 30 comments in an hour average, so I wouldn’t pay somebody to leave comments unless I made more per hour with another online activity to compensate.
Hey Justin thanks for the reply,
I have found out that a lot of these blog commenting services use auto post software and post your comments to spammed to hell webpages with 1000′s of comments. I see these blog commenting services and their sales pitch makes you think you are getting ‘quality’ one way do follow links that will last forever …. Though most of these services, or even ALL that I have tried are no where near what they advertise.
I’m really not thinking that I am going to get ahead now by paying a comment service, as you said Comluv and sites like keywordluv along with 1000′s of drupal blogs are do follow, it’s just the hassle of putting in the work, and I am lazy and really don’t like commenting for endless hours to boost my pagerank and keyword authority, but actually reviewing blog commenting services has been a fun little project for me and if there is one out there that is legit I will let it be known